The study evaluates the performance of lpa mtbdrplus compared to proportional method pm. What sample was used to diagnose the tb and what was the reading on the bands. Another identification option the line probe assay. Robustness of the line probe assay for the rapid diagnosis. The line probe assay lpa is a promising rapid diagnostic tool, based on a combination of the multiplex polymerase chain reaction followed by the dna strip reverse hybridization assay. Although lpas are more technically complex designed for reference or regional laboratory settings and take longer to perform than the xpert mtbrif assay cepheid, sunnyvale, ca, usa, they. In 2015, the manufacturer developed and made commercially available version 2. Line probe assays for drugresistant tuberculosis detection 2 laboratory staff and clinicians on the interpretation of the results for both, fl and sllpa, and to better understand and manage possible discrepancies between phenotypic and genotypic dst. Evaluation of a new line probe assay for rapid identification of. Comparative evaluation of genotype mtbdrplus line probe. However, until this study there have been few data on direct testing of. Molecular line probe assay for the detection of resistance to second line antitb drugs sllpa diagnostics background multidrug resistant tuberculosis mdr tb is a public health crisis and a global health security risk carrying grave consequences for those affected.
Technical faqs on hain genotype mtbdrplus line probe assay 2 conventional tests for tb involve afb smear, culture and dst. All isolates tested by pyrosequencing n 5 were concordant with the line probe assay for fq resistance with identical mutations d94g and four of five isolates were concordant with slids with identical mutations a1401g. Role of molecular methods in tuberculosis diagnosis and treatment. Line probe assays lpas enable rapid drugsusceptibility testing for rifampicin rif and isoniazid inh resistance and mycobacterium tuberculosis detection. February 20 this report contains the collective views of an international group of experts, and does not necessarily represent the decisions or the stated policy of the world health organization. Please refer to the genotype mtbdrplus kit insert for more details related to the procedure, precautions, interpretation, limitations and troubleshooting. Tb online who recommends use of two alternative line. Microscopy cannot detect drug resistance, while the mtbdrplus can rapidly detect resistance to rifampicin and isoniazid, the most important firstline tb drugs. However, there is no clarity regarding the superiority of one over the other. Pdf performance of line probe assay mtbdrplus in the. Technical faqs on hain genotype mtbdrplus line probe assay. We have compared direct sequencing to a line probe assay lipa for the detection of drug resistancerelated mutations in 197 clinical samples, and we have investigated the sequential appearance of mutations under drug pressure. Published studies have shown that the assay performs well when using culture isolates.
To 1 verify the validity of a new line probe assay for hepatitis c virus hcv genotyping and 2 determine the distribution of hcv genotypes and the association between hcv genotype and clinical variables in patients with chronic hepatitis c seen in tertiary referral centers in the united states. Line probe assay connecting our members with evidence and. Rapid confirmation of diagnosis of mtb and mdrmtb in clinical samples by line probe assays based on reverse dna hybridizationrdh methods. Validation of the ntmdr line probe assay employing nontuberculous mycobacterial whole genomic sequence data as reference standard l.
Journal of pathogens hindawi publishing corporation. The development of rapid molecular diagnostic assays for pyrazinamide pza resistance is considered technically challenging as mutations are highly diverse, scattered along the full length of the pnca gene and not all are associated with pza resistance. Molecular line probe assay for the detection of resistance to second line antitb drugs sllpa tuberculosis diagnostics background multidrug resistant tuberculosis mdr tb is a public health crisis and a global health security risk carrying grave consequences for those affected. Pdf comparison of xpert mtbrif with line probe assay for.
We evaluated the performance of the novel genoscholar pzatb ii line probe assay pzalpa2. The contents in this lecture are based on the existing guidelines publications during this period. Evaluation of two line probe assays for rapid detection of. Evaluation of the aid esbl line probe assay for rapid. Comparison of dna sequencing and a line probe assay for. Line probe assays lpas enable rapid drugsusceptibility testing for. The line probe assay gave hundred percent interpretable results with 2. Diagnostic utility of a line probe assay for multidrug resistant. The use of molecular line probe assays for the detection.
Nov 18, 2015 06 november 2015 who has approved the use of two alternative line probe assays lpas, with the capability to detect tb and rifampicin resistance. Rdh is useful for detection of mutations related to drug resistance in mycobacterium tuberculosis. The line probe invalid rates were substantially lower, at 1. Pdf clinical biotechnology and microbiology research. Line probe assay has been shown to be highly sensitive and specific in the detection of rifampicinresistant tb when used on culture isolates. The test was based on the same principle as the commercial line probe assay for rapid determination of rifampin rmp resistance, the innolipa rif. The objectives of the study were to compare the performance of line probe assay genotype mtbdrplus with solid culture method for an early diagnosis of multidrug resistant tuberculosis mdrtb, and to study the mutation patterns associated with rpob, katg and inha genes at a tertiary care centre in north india.
Molecular detection of drugresistant tuberculosis by line. If the clinical picture is highly suggestive of tb, a repeat test can be ordered to increase sensitivity. Viral extraction is performed using the roche magna pure lc. This test may yield an indeterminate result if the hcv viral load is less than the limit of detection. As it is we are not able to ascertain what kind of results you have since lpa will also give inh and rif sensitivity patterns. Comparison of genexpert and line probe assay for detection of.
The test was performed according to the manufacturers protocol hain life science gmbh, nehren, germany. This assay promises to be an asset for health care providers who require an understanding of antimicrobial. Accuracy of line probe assays for the diagnosis of pulmonary and. Genotype mtbdrsl line probe assay shortens time to. The line probe assay lpa, based on strip technology was used to diagnose tb and detect rif as well as isoniazid inh resistance due to mutations in rpo. A liquid culture will be the most definitive way of ruling out tb. Muhammad yahya noori assistant professor department of pathology dimc focal person for provincial tuberculosis reference lab sindh duhs 2. Background the objectives of the study were to compare the performance of line probe assay genotype mtbdrplus with solid culture method for an early diagnosis of multidrug resistant tuberculosis mdrtb, and to study the mutation patterns associated with rpob, katg and inha genes at a tertiary care centre in north india. The world health organization validates the use of line probe assay lpa for rapid detection of mdrtb. Utility of line probe assay for the early detection of. This metaanalysis suggests that the lipa assay is highly sensitive and specific for detecting rifampicinresistant tb both in. Pdf line probe assay for detection of mycobacterium tuberculosis. Pdf comparison of xpert mtbrif with line probe assay. A commercial line probe assay for the rapid detection of.
Multicenter evaluation of the molecular line probe assay for. May 06, 2019 disclaimer this lecture was developed during the period november 2017 to july 2018. Line probe assays for drug resistant tuberculosis detection. Comparison of xpert mtbrif with line probe assay for. Testing a set of 424 clinical enterobacteriaceae strains showed 100% sensitivity and specificity for the detection and differentiation of tem, shv and ctxm esbl genes present in that group. There is a paucity of data on application of this test directly to clinical specimens, although based on a. The line probe assay was shown to detect with 100% accuracy esbl genes for which oligonucleotide probes are present in the assay. Evaluation of genexpert mtbrif and line probe assay for rapid diagnosis of mycobacterium tuberculosis in sudanese pulmonary tb patients. Jan 04, 2016 the line probe assay uses the reverse hybridization technology. Initial growth, detection and identification may take 2 8 weeks and susceptibility testing for first line drugs on solid.
Probe sequences were optimized carefully to permit genotyping of all alleles under the same assay conditions. Prewarm the twin incubator to 45 c and hyb green and str red solutions to 37 45 c in a. Secondgeneration line probe assay for hepatitis c virus genotyping. Line probe assays lpas are rapid molecular diagnostics that can detect m. The use of molecular line probe assays for the detection of. Line probe assay for detection of mycobacterium tuberculosis. This follows the 2008 recommendation by who on the use of lpas for the rapid detection of rifampicin resistance. Comparative evaluation of genotype mtbdrplus line probe assay. In r5, the six selected probes were used for types. Genotype mtbdrsl line probe assay shortens time to diagnosis.
The ntmdr line probe assay offers an accurate and faster alternative to currently available approaches for identifying the most frequently encountered ntm species and subspecies of m. The procedure takes advantage of the fact that, under appropriate reaction conditions, a short oligonucleotide probe will hybridize to its target only when it is perfectly matched. The line probe assay is used for the diagnosis of mdrtb. Comparison of genexpert and line probe assay for detection.
A commercial line probe assay for the rapid detection of rifampicin. It can directly show the change in flexibility and binding of regions of rna in response to a ligand, as well as compare that response to analogous ligands. Multicenter evaluation of the molecular line probe assay. Distribution of hepatitis c virus genotypes determined by. Tuberculosis most common infectious cause of mortality after hivaids 2 3. The resistance of human immunodeficiency virus type 1 hiv1 to drugs is a major cause of antiretroviral treatment failure. When considering line probe assay performance in comparison to culturebased methods, liquidbased mycobacterial culture is limited by contamination rates that can be as high as 14. The hcv genotype test will be cancelled for samples that. Line probe assay connecting our members with evidence. Molecular lineprobe assay for the detection of resistance to secondline antitb drugs sllpa tuberculosis diagnostics background multidrug resistant tuberculosis mdr tb is a public health crisis and a global health security risk carrying grave consequences for those affected. Costeffectiveness and costbenefit of line probe assays remain to be assessed, and will be. Of these 30% were cases known to be mdr cases as detected from. Accuracy of line probe assays for the diagnosis of pulmonary.
Technical faqs on hain genotype mtbdrplus line probe assay 3 is 98. Validation of the ntmdr line probe assay employing. Disclaimer this lecture was developed during the period november 2017 to july 2018. In a doubleblinded prospective study, we evaluated the efficacy of the xpert mtbrif on samples that were first tested by lpa under the revised national.
Accuracy of line probe assays for the diagnosis of pulmonary and multidrugresistant tuberculosis. The target dna, previously extracted by boiling, is pcramplified using biotinylated primers and finally incubated with the strip. Development and evaluation of a pcrbased, line probe assay. Jul 28, 2005 line probe assay has been shown to be highly sensitive and specific in the detection of rifampicinresistant tb when used on culture isolates. Subtype information is available in the majority of cases. Can use mgit liquid culture and solid media quick visual interpretation mostly automated using the auto. Hain line probe assay hain lpa is a fast and reliable method to determine resistance to rifampicin and isoniazid by detecting rpob, katg, and inha genes mutation and was evaluated in a variety of settings34. The mtbdrplus line probe assay lpa and xpert mtbrif have been endorsed by the world health organization for the rapid diagnosis of drugresistant tuberculosis. Role of molecular methods in tuberculosis diagnosis and. The lineprobe assay uses the reverse hybridization technology. Genotype mtbdr plus assay was directly applied to smearpositive specimens around usd1719 and highest when the assay was used on isolates from liquid primary culture around usd25 35. Only 25% of multidrugresistant tuberculosis mdrtb cases are currently diagnosed. There was a marked offset at the end of the bioreactor run, suggesting the ability of the canty analyzer to correlated to early and late stages of apoptosis. The mtbdrsl test is a molecular line probe assay for the rapid detection of mutations associated with resistance to fluoroquinolone and aminoglycoside antibiotics and cycloserine, drugs used to treat multidrugresistant tuberculosis.
Accuracy of line probe assays for the diagnosis of. Helstrom2, michael strong1, max salfinger2 1center for genes, environment and health, and. Inline probing is a functional assay that can be used to determine structural changes in rna in response to ligand binding. Efficacy of line probe assay in detection of drugresistant pulmonary tuberculosis in comparison with genexpert and phenotypic methods in iran and genetic analysis of isolates by miruvntr. We would like to show you a description here but the site wont allow us. Tb online who recommends use of two alternative line probe. Thus, although the assay correctly identified the r553x mutation in a heterozygous state, the lack of hybridization with the g551d wildtype probe absence of signal in the wildtype allele indicated the need for additional analysis to determine the genotype of the sample.
Comparison of xpert mtbrif with line probe assay for detection of rifampinmonoresistant mycobacterium tuberculosis. Mycobacterium tuberculosis complex may sometimes not be detected in sputum samples of suspected multidrugresistant. Rise in multidrug resistant tuberculosis mdrtb, emergence of extensively drug resistant tuberculosis xdrtb and high mortality of mdrtb and xdrtb patients stresses the need for rapid diagnostic tests to detect drug resistant. Hainline probe assays advantages works on processed specimens rapid assay improved instrumentation for analysis and documentation of results used in laboratories now disadvantages multiple beacons needed to cover overlapping regions silent mutations may result in false predication of resistance not customizable by user. The mtbdrsl is a useful test for accurate diagnosis of xdrtb and may help to tailor therapy.
Methods in this crosssectional study, 269 previously treated sputum. The sample size of 50 afb staining positive sputum samples taken was tested. Pdf evaluation of genexpert mtbrif and line probe assay. Displaying line probe assay principle powerpoint presentations there was a marked offset at the end of the bioreactor ppt presentation summary. There is a paucity of data on application of this test directly to clinical specimens, although based on a small number of studies, the test appears to be less promising. Genotype mtbdrplusv1 was whoendorsed in 2008 but newer lpas have since been developed. Line probe assay conclusion advantages easy to perform detection of 18 clinically relevant mycobacteriumsp. Development and evaluation of a pcrbased, line probe. Molecular lineprobe assay for the detection of resistance to secondline antitb drugs sllpa diagnostics background multidrug resistant tuberculosis mdr tb is a public health crisis and a global health security risk carrying grave consequences for those affected. This assay became the gold standard for tb drug susceptibility testing dst. Line probe assay lipa based rapid detection of multiple. The following steps are for the development of the assays manually. At that time, the evidence assessed was for the lpa technology, hain version 1 assay. In 2008, hain lpa was endorsed by the who for mdr tb screening5.
1084 707 613 122 257 1341 607 851 156 1328 976 1480 833 1193 1365 418 779 820 1579 643 809 1443 785 1022 1586 16 428 134 1324 556 1130 65 1472 343 237 157 330 988 755 1129 65 1032 1120 1179 408 1487 1172 735 975 1187